Harry Maguire’s 93rd-minute header, appearing offside, secures Manchester United’s 2-1 FA Cup win over Leicester City

In a dramatic FA Cup fourth-round tie at Old Trafford, Manchester United edged past Leicester City with a 2-1 victory, courtesy of a contentious 93rd-minute header by captain Harry Maguire. The match, held on February 7, 2025, was fraught with tension and controversy.

Leicester City drew first blood just before the half-time whistle, with Bobby De Cordova-Reid capitalising on a defensive lapse to put the visitors ahead. Manchester United’s initial performance was lacklustre, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning their resolve.

The second half saw a rejuvenated United side. Manager Ruben Amorim’s decision to introduce Alejandro Garnacho proved pivotal. The young winger injected much-needed energy into the squad, playing a crucial role in the build-up to the equaliser. In the 68th minute, Joshua Zirkzee found the back of the net, restoring parity and reigniting the contest.

As the match seemed destined for extra time, a twist unfolded. Deep into stoppage time, Bruno Fernandes delivered a precise free-kick into the box. Harry Maguire rose above the Leicester defence, directing a powerful header past the goalkeeper. However, replays indicated that Maguire was in an offside position when the ball was played. The absence of VAR at this stage of the competition meant the goal stood, sealing United’s progression to the fifth round.

Leicester City’s manager, Ruud van Nistelrooy, was visibly incensed by the decision. A former Manchester United striker himself, van Nistelrooy remarked, “It’s unacceptable. The goal was clearly offside. My players deserved the opportunity to fight in extra time.” His sentiments were echoed by many, as debates about the necessity of VAR in all rounds of the FA Cup resurfaced.

Manchester United’s Ruben Amorim acknowledged the fortuitous nature of the victory. “We were lucky with the decision,” he admitted. “Our first-half performance was below par, but the lads showed character in the second half. We must do better.”

The match has since been the subject of intense discussion. Pundit Roy Keane didn’t mince words, labelling United’s first-half display as “shocking” and “poor.” He expressed bewilderment at the officiating, stating, “I can’t understand how the linesman missed that offside. It’s a clear error.”

This encounter has reignited debates about the implementation of VAR in earlier rounds of the FA Cup. Many argue that such technology is essential to ensure fairness, especially in high-stakes matches where a single decision can alter the course of a team’s campaign.

For Manchester United, this victory marks their third win in eight home games across all competitions, offering a glimmer of hope amidst a season of mixed fortunes. As they advance to the fifth round, questions linger about their consistency and the role of technology in modern football.