New Zealand’s Scott Robertson defends the haka, calling it an integral part of their identity, after England’s Joe Marler labelled it “ridiculous
As the highly anticipated Autumn Nations Series match approaches, New Zealand‘s head coach Scott Robertson has hit back at England prop Joe Marler’s recent comments regarding the All Blacks’ iconic haka. Marler, who stirred controversy with his remarks, described the traditional Māori challenge as “ridiculous” in a post on X, later attempting to clarify that he was merely trying to inject some fun into the buildup to what promises to be an exhilarating rugby showdown at Twickenham on Saturday, 2 November.
Robertson, who took over as head coach of the All Blacks after their defeat in the final of the 2023 Rugby World Cup, expressed disappointment at Marler’s choice of words. “I know Joe,” Robertson remarked. “I wonder if he wished he could have articulated himself a little bit better on that.” For the All Blacks, the haka is far more than just a pre-match ritual; it represents a deep-rooted cultural heritage that embodies their national identity. “The haka for us is a custom – it is part of who we are, it’s our DNA. It means a lot to us,” he asserted.
The comments have not gone unnoticed within the All Blacks camp. Robertson revealed that Marler’s post was discussed among his players, highlighting its significance. However, he clarified that they wouldn’t use it as an opportunity to portray it as disrespectful. “We don’t use it as such to say, ‘this is what has been said and it’s disrespectful’. Especially in this regard, because it has happened before. But we will discuss it and decide how we deal with it respectfully.”
Marler’s remarks have drawn backlash not only from rugby fans but also from political and cultural figures in New Zealand. His statements have added to the pre-match tension as the All Blacks gear up for a fierce contest against England, a rivalry that has intensified in recent years, particularly after their recent encounter with Ireland. In response to the criticism, Marler apologised for his “poorly articulated” comments, acknowledging that he might have sparked unnecessary controversy.
England captain Jamie George voiced his disagreement with Marler, affirming his appreciation for the haka’s historical significance in rugby. “I love the history of the haka,” George said, recalling his childhood memories as a rugby fan. “It was always something I enjoyed watching.” He acknowledged the different opinions within the team, remarking, “Joe and I don’t always agree on everything and we disagree on this topic. I guess he’s prodded the bear a little bit.”
Assistant coach Kevin Sinfield also distanced himself from Marler’s views. Sinfield, who has experienced the haka both as a player and a coach, emphasised its importance in rugby culture. “I think it is an important part of this fixture,” he said, expressing his excitement for the match. “You will see 82,000 people on Saturday who cannot wait to see it, and I will be one of them.”
With the match set to unfold at the Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, the focus will inevitably shift back to the pitch, where players’ performances will overshadow the pre-match exchanges. Sinfield pointed out the irony in the situation, stating, “But the funny thing is, there is all the chat before and afterwards, but it is a very little part of what goes on on the field. The players dictate what happens out there.”
As the All Blacks prepare for their showdown with England, Robertson’s remarks reflect a commitment to uphold the integrity and significance of the haka while also acknowledging the ongoing conversation around cultural respect in sport. The anticipation builds as rugby fans await the clash, eager to witness not only the fierce competition but also the rich traditions that make rugby such a revered sport.
