Ellis Jenkins slams Warren Gatland review remarks, calling them a missed opportunity to address Welsh rugby’s struggles

Warren Gatland review remarks criticizing feedback from an independent review of Welsh rugby have sparked backlash, with former flanker Ellis Jenkins labelling his comments as “poor.” The review followed Wales’ record-breaking 12-Test losing streak, culminating in a disastrous 2024 Autumn Nations Series.

At the announcement of Wales’ Six Nations squad, Gatland questioned the value of input from players and review participants. “What has their experience been in a professional winning environment?” he asked, referencing both the players and external contributors.

Jenkins, speaking on Scrum V: The Warm Up, expressed dismay at Gatland’s remarks. “I was really surprised,” he said. “To question the players and the validity of their feedback just because they haven’t been part of a winning campaign is poor. You don’t have to act on all feedback, but it should at least be considered.”

The context of Gatland’s frustration is stark. Wales haven’t won a Test since their group-stage victory over Georgia at the 2023 Rugby World Cup, and the national team’s struggles have been mirrored across all levels of Welsh rugby. Gatland acknowledged as much, stating, “We’re probably a reflection of what Welsh rugby is like.”

However, Jenkins argues that disregarding players’ opinions undermines efforts to rebuild. “Players aren’t complaining for the sake of it,” he said. “Everyone at this level wants to improve. Suggestions should be met productively, even if not all are implemented.”

The fallout from Gatland’s comments comes amid broader turmoil in Welsh rugby. WRU Chief Executive Abi Tierney reaffirmed Gatland’s role after the review, but leadership instability persists. Nigel Walker departed as executive director of rugby in December, shortly after Ioan Cunningham’s resignation as Wales women’s head coach.

Former centre Jonathan Davies also weighed in, cautioning against public criticism of the review process. “If Gats isn’t happy, it should be handled behind closed doors. From the outside, it seems feathers have been ruffled.”

Despite the controversies, Jenkins and Davies agree on one point: allowing players to voice opinions is crucial for progress. “Coaches won’t keep everyone happy, but hearing and acknowledging players’ feedback is how you improve as a team,” Jenkins emphasised.

Wales’ Six Nations opener against France in Paris on 31 January looms as a daunting test. Gatland’s comments have added to the tension, leaving Welsh rugby at a crossroads as it seeks to reverse its fortunes.