A dramatic tie forces Claudia Winkleman to leave Celebrity Traitors’ fate to chance
Fans of The Celebrity Traitors were left gasping in disbelief tonight as a shocking twist threw the competition into complete chaos. In an unprecedented moment, two Faithful contestants — actor Mark Bonnar and historian David Olusoga — faced an impossible dilemma when the roundtable vote ended in a deadlock, forcing host Claudia Winkleman to declare their banishment would be left “to the hands of fate.”
The dramatic tie came after an intense episode already reeling from Charlotte Church’s surprise “murder,” which sent shockwaves through the castle. Just as the surviving contestants thought the night couldn’t get any worse, the roundtable descended into turmoil when two of the most trusted players found themselves neck and neck in the final vote.
When the votes were counted, both Mark and David had received the same number, sparking confusion and panic among the remaining Faithfuls. A visibly stunned Winkleman announced, “Players, it is still a draw. Therefore, we will now leave this banishment to the hands of fate.”
The room fell silent. Comedian Lucy Beaumont broke the tension, asking nervously, “Has this ever happened before?” Her question was met by a wide-eyed Nick Mohammad, who admitted, “It’s never happened.” The stunned group could only watch as Winkleman confirmed that the decision would be left to chance — though how that fate would be decided remains a mystery until the next episode.
Embed from Getty Images
Viewers watching at home erupted online, with many struggling to contain their shock. “What the h**l does leaving it up to fate mean?! Do they have to flip a coin???” one fan posted on X, while another exclaimed, “What do you MEAN they’re leaving the banishment in the hands of FATE?! AND a cliffhanger?!”
Social media was ablaze with theories about how the tiebreaker would unfold. Some viewers joked about dice rolls and card draws, while others speculated that the production team had devised a new twist never before seen on the show.
The cliffhanger was made even more dramatic by the fact that both Mark and David are Faithful — a cruel irony that means whichever one is sent home, the real Traitors will remain untouched for another day. Fans have already predicted grim consequences for whoever survives.
“Well whoever survives tonight is absolute f****d tomorrow,” one fan wrote. Another agreed: “Whoever stays tonight will not be murdered in the turret. And will probably be banished tomorrow.” A third echoed the sentiment, predicting, “Whoever stays tomorrow will be banished next week.”
The historic tie marks the first time in Traitors history that a roundtable banishment has been left purely to chance. It has thrown the game into unprecedented territory, leaving contestants and viewers alike questioning what fate truly means in this ruthless psychological battle.
Earlier in the episode, the shock murder of singer Charlotte Church had already shaken the castle to its core. The Faithfuls’ failure to correctly identify the Traitors has continued to erode trust, turning each roundtable into a volatile mix of paranoia and panic.
As the Faithfuls prepare for another night of anxiety and betrayal, the looming question remains: how will fate decide who leaves next?
The teaser for tomorrow’s episode promises “a decision like no other,” suggesting that the game’s most unpredictable moment is yet to come. Whether it’s luck, strategy, or pure chaos that determines who survives, one thing is certain — The Celebrity Traitors has delivered its most nerve-shredding cliffhanger yet.