New Yorkers debate authenticity of Lopez’s “orange drink” order

Jennifer Lopez‘s revelation of her go-to bodega order has stirred up a whirlwind of reactions among New Yorkers. In a clip from her film, “This Is Me … Now: A Love Story,” Lopez shares her preferred bodega choice: a ham and cheese on a roll, a small bag of chips, and an elusive “orange drink.” Her casual mention of the drink, accompanied by the phrase “If you know, you know,” left many scratching their heads, unsure of what specific beverage she referred to.

This ambiguity triggered a flurry of activity on social media platforms like TikTok, where users embarked on a quest to unravel the mystery of the orange drink. Videos flooded in, with TikTokers heading to Bronx bodegas to recreate Lopez’s order, documenting their experiences and the varied interpretations of the infamous orange beverage.

Gianna Christine, one TikTok user, ventured into Adam’s Deli in the Bronx, aiming to nail down Lopez’s exact order. Despite her efforts, Christine found herself baffled by the array of orange drinks available, from Crush to Sunkist, highlighting the challenge of pinning down what Lopez’s “If you know, you know” drink could be. Despite initial scepticism, Christine rated the meal a perfect score upon tasting it, acknowledging the unexpected satisfaction it provided.

Another TikToker, Cara, echoed this sentiment, documenting her own journey to secure the “J. Lo” order. Her choice of a Fanta as the mysterious orange drink showcased the personal interpretation involved in replicating the order, suggesting the possibility that the original beverage might no longer be available.

Amidst the playful scrutiny, some defended Lopez, pointing out the commonality of her bodega choice back in the day, emphasizing that the combination of a sandwich, chips, and a drink was a staple. However, the debate extended beyond the items themselves to their specific naming and customization, which, according to New Yorkers, is where the true essence of a bodega order lies.

WellWithTiffany, a TikToker from Brooklyn, highlighted the complexity behind what might seem like a simple ham and cheese sandwich, noting that the expectation in New York is to specify additional toppings and preferences, thus enriching the order beyond its basic components.

The discourse surrounding Lopez’s bodega order illuminates a broader conversation about cultural authenticity and the nuances of everyday New York life. It demonstrates how something as straightforward as a bodega order can serve as a litmus test for one’s connection to their roots, sparking lively discussions and introspection among the city’s residents.

As TikTokers and New Yorkers alike continue to dissect Lopez’s bodega order, the conversation transcends food, touching on identity, nostalgia, and the ever-evolving nature of urban culture. While the debate over the “orange drink” may seem lighthearted, it underscores a deeper appreciation for the personal stories and communal experiences that shape life in the Bronx and beyond